Skip to content
  • News
  • Blueprints
  • Events
  • Teach
  • Contribute
  • Volunteer
  • Support us
  • About

Diversity Reading List

Helping you include authors from under-represented groups in your teaching

Read freeSee used
Allen, Anita L.. Mental Disorders and the “System of Judgmental Responsibility”
2010, Boston University Law Review 90: 621-640.
Categories: Metaethics, Moral Psychology, Psychiatry
Keywords: determinism, moral agency, responsibility

Added by: Simon Fokt
Diversifying Syllabi: Thesis: Those affected by mental disorders whose actions are episodically influenced by their disorder are often overlooked by philosophers of moral and ethical responsibility. Allen gives us reasons for thinking it is inappropriate to either: a) “summarily exclude people with mental problems out of the universe of moral agents, reducing them to the status of rocks, trees, animals, and infants” b) “include the group on the false assumption that their moral lives are precisely like the paradigmatic moral lives of the epistemically-sound and well-regulated people never personally touched by a mental condition” We must explore a revised approach to moral and ethical responsibility and obligation for this group.

Comment: This text is useful in teaching in two main contexts: (1) in discussing ethical issues related to mental disorders; and (2) to provide a challenging case in classes on blame and responsibility. The text can be also used in the context of the free will and determinism debate, and as a further reading in classes on moral agency.

Difficulty: Easy
Recommended use: Introductory reading
Comments (0): Read and add advice on using this text below.

Export citation in BibTeX format

Export text citation

View this text on PhilPapers

Export citation in Reference Manager format

Export citation in EndNote format

Export citation in Zotero format

Share on Twitter
Share on Facebook
Share on LinkedIn
Share by Email

Categories

.
(20)
Aesthetics
(230)
Aesthetic Experience and Judgement
(106)
Aesthetic Normativity and Value
(117)
Artistic Movements
(7)
Artistry and Creativity
(16)
Ethics and Socio-Politics of Aesthetics
(90)
Individual Arts and Crafts
(95)
Metaphysics of Aesthetics
(92)
Epistemology
(257)
Applied Epistemology
(53)
Formal Epistemology
(16)
Metaepistemology
(27)
Social Epistemology
(82)
Standpoint Epistemology
(13)
Theoretical Epistemology
(156)
Metaphilosophy
(157)
Ethics and Socio-Politics of Philosophy
(56)
Historiography of Philosophy
(52)
Philosophical Biography
(15)
Philosophical Media and Methodology
(88)
Philosophical Translation and/or Commentary
(18)
Philosophy Education
(10)
The Nature, Value, and Aims of Philosophy
(22)
Metaphysics
(281)
Causation
(64)
Free Will
(27)
Identity and Change
(56)
Mereology
(7)
Metametaphysics
(7)
Modality
(33)
Ontology and Metaontology
(165)
Properties, Propositions, and Relations
(24)
Space, Time, and Space-Time
(26)
Truth and Truthmaking
(23)
Moral Philosophy
(576)
Applied Ethics
(383)
Descriptive Ethics
(4)
Metaethics
(178)
Moral Psychology
(24)
Normative Ethics
(143)
Philosophy of Action
(20)
Philosophy of Language
(125)
Communication
(45)
Ethics and Socio-Politics of Language
(43)
Grammar and Meaning
(80)
Language and Mind
(46)
Linguistics
(4)
Metaphysics of Language
(1)
Philosophy of Mind
(460)
Artificial Intelligence
(6)
Cognitive Science
(19)
Consciousness
(55)
Intentionality
(115)
Mental States and Processes
(352)
Metaphysics of Mind and Body
(84)
Neuroscience
(18)
Psychiatry
(16)
Psychology
(35)
Philosophy of Religion
(78)
Afterlife
(7)
Creation
(5)
Deities and their Attributes
(48)
Divination, Faith, and Miracles
(7)
Environment
(6)
Ethics and Socio-Politics of Religion
(5)
Religious Development, Experience, and Personhood
(39)
Theodicy
(14)
Philosophy of the Formal, Social, and Natural Sciences
(393)
Anthropology
(11)
Archaeology and History
(24)
Economics
(13)
Geography
(1)
Life Sciences
(109)
Logic and Mathematics
(166)
Physical Sciences
(106)
Psychology
(15)
Sociology
(15)
Political Philosophy
(432)
Equality
(117)
Forms of Government
(71)
Freedom and Rights
(158)
Justice
(270)
Law and Public Policy
(211)
Political Authority and Legitimacy
(37)
Political Economy
(25)
Political Ideologies
(13)
War and Peace
(17)
Social Philosophy
(706)
Class
(68)
Culture
(452)
Disability
(39)
Education
(36)
Gender, Sex, and Sexuality
(315)
Personal and Social Identity
(149)
Race
(165)
Sustainability
(23)
Technology and Material Culture
(12)
Work, Labor, and Leisure
(49)

Keywords

abortion aesthetics art art classification autonomy causation Chinese philosophy colonialism confucianism consciousness consent depiction desire disability epistemology equality ethics experimental philosophy feminism feminist philosophy fiction gender identity imagination justice Kant knowledge logic metaphysics methodology mind models perception philosophy of language philosophy of mind philosophy of religion philosophy of science portrait race representation responsibility science sex truth virtue

Our Sponsors

Arts and Humanities Research Council
American Philosophical Association
British Philosophical Association
Marc Sanders FoundationMarc Sanders Foundation
Society for Applied Philosophy
American Society for Aesthetics
University of St Andrews
University of Manchester
University of Sheffield
The University of Leeds
The University of Edinburgh
EIDYN
British Society of Aesthetics
The White Rose College of the Arts & Humanities
  • Creative Commons Attribution license

    Unless otherwise stated, all elements of the Diversity Reading List licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution Non-Derivatives 4.0 International License
    Web Design by TELdesign Limited • Theme: Avant by Kaira

    filtration

Theme: Avant by Kaira
This site is registered on Toolset.com as a development site.